Welcome, Neighbor!

We make insurance easy
so you can focus on what you love.

Get a Quote


Hippo Home InsuranceMercury Auto and Home InsuranceProgressive Auto and Home InsuranceSafeco Auto and Home InsuranceState Auto Home InsuranceTravelers Auto and Home Insurance

Protecting What Matters To You

Neighbor's Choice Insurance has been serving the insurance needs of our neighbors in Grapevine and surrounding communities since 1991. We work with our clients to protect what matters most to them. 

When you choose Neighbor’s Choice Insurance, you get insurance advice from a local experienced agent, along with the most competitive insurance rates available in your area. Our agency works with you as your insurance needs change over time and monitors your rates for as long as you’re part of our agency.

As an independent insurance agency, we search multiple insurance companies to find you the best value on your auto, home, life, boat, motorcycle and RV insurance. Insurance doesn't have to be difficult. We work hard to make it easy.

Start your insurance quote today! Call us at (817) 421-8866 or Start An Online Quote

How We Can Help

  • Personal service, free insurance quotes and advice for all your insurance needs.
  • Comparison of coverage options and insurance rates from several different companies to find the best combination of coverage and price.
  • Trained insurance professionals who understand your insurance needs and can ensure you have the appropriate insurance rates and accompanying coverage.

5 out of 5 stars
Total Reviews : 33

Schedule a Consultation Call

Auto Insurance

Get the right protection for your ride at a competitive price.
Auto Insurance Auto Quote

Home Insurance

Every family is unique and your insurance should be too.
Home Insurance Home Quote

Life Insurance

Insure the future of those you love against financial hardship.
Life Insurance Life Quote

What Our Clients Say About Us

“We’ve known Jeff and Wendy for years, and they have become like family to us. We really appreciate their industry knowledge and their ability to walk us through the best insurance options for us because they know our family so well. Looking forward to many more years with them!”
- Charles N. - Grapevine, TX

“Neighbor’s Choice is a wonderful insurance agency. I have used them for years. They give me the best rates along with exceptional customer service. Anytime I need help with my coverage, I can always count on Jeff and Wendy to go above and beyond to ensure my needs are met. I am very happy with choosing them!”
- Mallory M. – Lewisville, TX

“We have worked with Jeff and Wendy at Neighbor’s Choice Insurance Agency for our Homeowners and Auto insurance. From the moment we first met with them they have listened closely to our needs for both of these insurances to determine which would be the best policies and companies to place our insurance with. They have always been available to us quickly to answer all of our questions as our needs changed. We wouldn't go anywhere else for all of our personal insurance. They are among the best independent insurance agents we have ever worked with. We highly recommend Wendy and Jeff at Neighbors Choice Insurance.”
- Larry F. – Grapevine, TX

Insurance Agents and Owners Jeff and Wendy Caplinger

Agents and Owners Jeff and Wendy Caplinger